Every month, I love seeing what you gravitate toward most here on Beautifully Seaside—and May’s favorites were a dreamy mix of coastal wardrobe staples, beauty must-haves, and classic pieces that feel just right for summer. From nautical embroidery to breezy blues and easy throw-on-and-go styles, you all had amazing taste this month (as usual!).
Here’s what topped the list—the pieces that were most clicked, shopped, and loved by readers. If you’re just catching up or want to grab a few favorites before they sell out, many of these are still in stock and so worth it!
The Most Popular Finds on Beautifully Seaside in May
Nautical Embroidered Cardigan
This cozy-chic cardigan had serious coastal charm and was one of the most popular pieces all month long. The sweet embroidery details give it that timeless, New England-inspired look we all adore. Shop it here
Lace Trim Slip Dress in the Prettiest Blue
This dress is truly something special. Light, floaty, and so flattering—it’s perfect for summer date nights, beach weddings, or just feeling beautiful on a random Tuesday. The blue is even prettier in person. Shop it here
Drawstring Denim Shorts
Easy, relaxed, and ridiculously comfortable. These shorts feel like a weekend at the beach and were a hit for good reason. I’ve been wearing mine nonstop with tees and tanks. Shop them here
Beek White Slides
Minimal, comfy, and perfect for casual summer days. These white slides were a top pick this month and give any outfit that breezy, lived-in coastal look. Shop them here
Under the Sea Print Dress
This dress feels like it belongs in a Nancy Meyers movie. The playful print and easy fit made it a standout piece—and it sold like crazy! A fun way to add a little summer whimsy to your wardrobe. Shop it here
Colleen Rothschild Sheer Renewal Cream
A skincare classic that made the top list again! I’ve used this for years and it always leaves my skin feeling soft, smooth, and glowy—especially after sun-filled days. Shop it here
Gold Sandals
These chic gold slides are that magical mix of polished and effortless. You loved them for everything from everyday errands to summer dinners—and they go with everything. Shop them here
White Stacked Button Wide Leg Jeans
So many of you clicked on these classic wide-leg jeans, and I totally understand why. The high waist, soft white denim, and vintage-inspired buttons make them feel so elevated. Shop them here
Hand-Knotted Bag
This bag was a favorite for good reason—it’s beautifully made, unique, and adds that artisan touch to any outfit. It’s the kind of piece that makes even a simple dress feel complete. Shop it here
Striped Pajama Pant Set
This dreamy striped pajama set was a reader favorite for good reason—super soft, lightweight, and exactly what you want to slip into after a long beach day (or just a regular Tuesday night). The classic stripe feels a little coastal, a little French girl, and very much like summer at home. Shop it here
May was filled with beautiful finds, and I loved seeing which ones became instant favorites for you. If you’re just catching up or want to treat yourself to something summery, I’ve linked everything above for easy browsing.
🐚 P.S. Want More Fresh Picks?
— J.Crew Just Dropped Their New Summer Collection—Here’s What I’m Eyeing
— These 9 Summer Staples Are So Good (I’ve Bought Them More Than Once)
— 11 Easy and Chic Pieces I Always Pack for a Coastal Escape
Leave a Reply